The Nova Craft Prospector strikes a perfect balance between ease of maneuverability (due to its 2.5 inch rocker) and straight tracking on flat water (partly due to a full length keel). The kids liked the maneuverability when soloing the boat and when they were exploring islands or fishing. They also appreciated the relatively straight tracking of the boat when we were on the flat water (on a recent trip we paddled for roughly 11 km on just the first lake.)
The boat is exceptionally stable, which is important when it is primarily being used by kids. On numerous occasions (when the kids took it to go swimming, exploring, or fishing) the boat was filled to the gills with kids and the movement of the kids in the boat did not pose a noticeable problem; the boat handled considerable side-to-side wobble without ever coming close to tipping.
The symmetrical shape of the boat allows the boat to be paddled backwards as easily as forwards, which is useful when one wants to solo the canoe from the front seat facing the stern. The absence of a thwart behind the front seat also makes this possible.
The 16' Nova Craft Prospector boasts a centre depth of 15 inches and a centre width of 36 inches. The upper end of its load capacity is 1000 pounds. We were able to comfortably fit two 60L barrels (with harnesses) side-by-side between the front seat and the yoke, and two small 30L barrels and some day bags between the back thwart and the yoke (see photo below). There is also room under the seats for smaller items such as camera gear and water bottles. The boat could easily handle all of the gear for two people going on a one- or two-week backcountry trip.
One of the features that I rather like about the Nova Craft Prospector is the relatively meaty aluminum gunwale design (you can get ash gunwales at an additional cost). The solid gunwales make it easy to pick the boat up from the side and ensure that the seats, thwart and yoke are firmly attached. We opted for the aluminum gunwales over the ash upgrade because the aluminum gunwales require less maintenance and have greater longevity when the canoe is stored outdoors.
As you can see in the image below, the paddler of the Nova Craft Prospector sits relatively high above the waterline and so it is advisable to use a paddle with a slightly longer shaft. The bow height of the Prospector is 23 inches, which is aesthetically appealing and useful when faced with large waves, but can be somewhat of a challenge in strong wind conditions.
In terms of build quality, I am happy to report that the Nova Craft Prospector has a solid and reliable build. The boat is available in several layups (fiberglass or the new TuffStuff material amongst others). While I would have preferred to go with the amazing TuffStuff, I decided to ultimately go with the much cheaper fiberglass version. I gather that nowadays fiberglass boats are considered to be mostly cottage boats, primarily because of their weight, which makes them somewhat difficult to portage (the 16' fiberglass Prospector is about 68 pounds in comparison to the TuffStuff version which is about 54 pounds). However, I don't mind carrying the extra weight on my shoulders when portaging, and the fiberglass version is much lighter on the wallet (which is important when your family has 7 people and the cost of camping gear is quite high). On our last trip, I portaged the Prospector for a total of roughly 1.3 km and it wasn't really a problem. Keep in mind that "back in the old days" most of the canoes were fiberglass and portaging a 65 pound canoe was a routine event. While I would recommend that you go with the TuffStuff layup (or even another lighter layup such as the aramid lite or the blue steel layups) if you have the cash, if money is an issue, just hit the gym during the year to make sure that you are made out of tuff stuff before canoe season begins so you can carry the fiberglass version :). The fiberglass version we purchased held up very well even though it made frequent (and sometimes somewhat careless) contact with rocky shores of the lakes in the Temagami region.
If there was one thing I would ask the good folks at Nova Craft to change about the boat it would be the yoke. The yoke included in this entry level boat is not really much of a yoke (it's more like a thwart), likely because, as I noted before, fiberglass boats are no longer meant for serious portaging. However, a deep dish yoke would be really helpful for those of us backcountry trippers strapped for cash, especially given the weight of the boat. In order to portage the boat, I had to resort to the old tried and true trick of lashing paddles between the yoke and the back thwart and carrying the boat on the cantilevered paddle blades (which was much more comfortable -- in fact, I actually like that better than the deep dish or contoured yokes on my other canoes). While MEC sells a deep dish yoke (for about $100) you can install yourself, I found that the ends of that deep dish yoke were much narrower than the ends of the yoke included with the boat, and I worried that there would just not be enough "meat" on the outsides of the screws to securely hold the yoke in place when the boat is on my shoulders. Also, what's the point of going with a cheaper boat if you have to spend hundreds in post-purchase upgrades? While I'm making suggestions, I should also mention that the kids complained a little about the comfort of the seats and the handles on the bow and stern; seats made from wide webbing would be preferred and more rounded handles would be much appreciated. Again, seats made from wide webbing can be purchased at MEC, but at an extra cost.
All things considered, however, I give the fiberglass/aluminum-trim Nova Craft 16' Prospector two thumbs up! It's a wonderful all-around backcountry canoe for the kids.